Blog

The Business Judgment Rule and Homeowners’ Associations: A Guide to New York and New Jersey Law

The Business Judgment Rule and Homeowners’ Associations in New York and New Jersey

Homeowners’ associations can exercise substantial authority over the communities they govern. Depending on the governing documents and applicable law, an association may regulate architectural changes, parking, pets, landscaping, common areas, assessments, maintenance, rentals, and many other aspects of life within a residential community.

Disputes inevitably arise. A homeowner may believe that a board’s decision is unfair, unreasonable, inconsistent with prior decisions, or simply wrong.

When such a dispute reaches court, however, the question is not always whether the judge agrees with the board’s decision. Both New York and New Jersey recognize versions of the business judgment rule, a doctrine that generally prevents courts from substituting their judgment for that of a properly acting association board.

The protection is substantial, but it is not unlimited. A board must have authority to act, and circumstances involving bad faith, fraud, self-dealing, unconscionable conduct, or other misconduct may justify judicial intervention.

The precise analysis also differs between New York and New Jersey.

What Is a Homeowners’ Association?

A homeowners’ association, commonly referred to as an HOA, is an organization responsible for governing and administering a residential community.

Typically, ownership of property within the development automatically makes the homeowner a member of the association. The rights and responsibilities of the association and homeowners are generally established through documents such as a declaration of covenants and restrictions, bylaws, rules and regulations, deeds, and other governing instruments.

Depending upon those documents and applicable law, an HOA may be responsible for:

  • maintaining common areas;
  • collecting assessments;
  • adopting budgets;
  • maintaining roads, landscaping, recreational facilities, and other common property;
  • regulating architectural modifications;
  • adopting parking and other community rules;
  • hiring contractors and managing agents;
  • maintaining insurance; and
  • enforcing restrictions contained in the community’s governing documents.

Homeowners’ associations, condominiums, and cooperative corporations are legally distinct forms of ownership and governance. Nevertheless, many of the leading cases concerning the business judgment rule arose in the cooperative and condominium context. Courts in both New York and New Jersey have applied the same general principles to homeowners’ associations and other common-interest communities.

What Is the Business Judgment Rule?

The business judgment rule originated in corporate law.

At its most basic level, the doctrine recognizes that directors—not judges—ordinarily manage the affairs of a corporation. Courts therefore generally will not substitute their judgment for an authorized business decision merely because someone believes the directors made a poor decision or could have made a better one.

The doctrine has particular importance in residential communities.

An HOA board routinely makes decisions about budgets, repairs, contractors, architectural restrictions, maintenance, parking, landscaping, assessments, and enforcement. Reasonable people can disagree about those decisions.

If every disagreement permitted a court to independently determine what it believed was best for the community, courts would effectively become substitute HOA boards.

The business judgment rule seeks to prevent that result.

It does not, however, mean that an HOA board can do whatever it wants. The board must possess authority to act, and the manner in which that authority is exercised remains subject to important legal limitations.

The Business Judgment Rule in New York

Matter of Levandusky: The Leading New York Case

The foundational New York case is Matter of Levandusky v. One Fifth Avenue Apartment Corp., 75 N.Y.2d 530 (1990).

Although Levandusky involved a cooperative apartment corporation rather than a traditional homeowners’ association, the New York Court of Appeals established principles that have subsequently been applied throughout New York common-interest-community law.

The Court adopted the business judgment rule as the appropriate standard for judicial review of decisions made by residential governing boards.

Under Levandusky, judicial deference generally applies when the board acts:

  • within the scope of its authority;
  • for the purposes of the residential community; and
  • in good faith.

The Court recognized that residential boards require broad discretion to govern effectively. Courts ordinarily should not substitute their judgment for that of a board merely because another decision might have been preferable.

At the same time, the Court recognized limits to that deference, including situations involving discrimination, self-dealing, bad faith, or other misconduct.

New York Applies the Business Judgment Rule to HOAs

New York’s appellate courts have expressly applied the business judgment rule to homeowners’ associations.

One particularly clear example is LoRusso v. Brookside Homeowner’s Association, Inc., 17 A.D.3d 323 (2d Dep’t 2005).

The Second Department explained that, absent fraud, self-dealing, unconscionability, or other misconduct, courts reviewing an HOA’s exercise of authority should apply the business judgment rule and generally limit their inquiry to whether the action was authorized, taken in good faith, and undertaken in furtherance of the legitimate interests of the association.

That principle has been applied repeatedly in disputes involving HOAs, condominiums, and other residential associations.

Captain’s Walk: Architectural Restrictions

Captain’s Walk Homeowners Association v. Penney, 17 A.D.3d 617 (2d Dep’t 2005) provides a particularly useful example.

The homeowner painted a walkway pink without obtaining the approval required by the association’s architectural guidelines. The HOA sought to compel restoration of the walkway to its original color.

The Second Department upheld the association’s action.

The important point is that the court did not undertake its own aesthetic analysis to determine whether a pink walkway was attractive or whether another color would have been preferable.

Instead, the relevant questions concerned the HOA’s authority, whether the board acted in good faith, and whether its action furthered legitimate association interests.

The case demonstrates the substantial deference that the business judgment rule can provide to an HOA board exercising authority granted by its governing documents.

What About Selective Enforcement in New York?

Selective enforcement is a more complicated issue.

Suppose an HOA prohibits a particular type of fence. Several homeowners have prohibited fences, but the association commences an enforcement proceeding against only one homeowner.

Does the fact that other homeowners apparently violated the same rule prevent the association from enforcing it?

The answer may depend heavily upon the particular facts.

In Captain’s Walk, the homeowner argued that the architectural guidelines had been selectively enforced. The Second Department nevertheless upheld the HOA’s action, observing that the homeowner had produced nothing beyond conclusory allegations of selective enforcement.

Similarly, in Skouras v. Victoria Hall Condominium, 73 A.D.3d 902 (2d Dep’t 2010), the Second Department upheld condominium board action under the business judgment rule and concluded that the owner had failed to raise a triable issue concerning allegations that she had been deliberately singled out for harmful treatment or that a parking rule had been selectively enforced.

On the other hand, Levandusky recognizes circumstances involving deliberate singling out of individuals for harmful treatment as potentially warranting judicial scrutiny.

Accordingly, homeowners and associations should be cautious about assuming that New York law establishes a simple rule that either all selective enforcement is permissible or all selective enforcement defeats the business judgment rule.

There is case law that may support arguments on either side depending upon what is meant by “selective enforcement” and, more importantly, the evidence supporting the claim.

The existence of another violation elsewhere in the community may present a very different case from evidence that a board intentionally targeted a particular homeowner because of personal hostility, discrimination, retaliation, self-interest, or another improper purpose.

Questions of waiver, estoppel, the similarity of the alleged violations, the association’s knowledge of other violations, prior approvals, non-waiver provisions in the governing documents, and the board’s reasons for different treatment may also affect the analysis.

For that reason, selective-enforcement disputes are particularly fact-sensitive and should be evaluated under the specific governing documents and circumstances rather than through a categorical rule.

The Board Must Have Authority to Act

The business judgment rule does not create authority that an HOA otherwise lacks.

This is an important distinction.

Before asking whether a board exercised its discretion properly, a court may first have to determine whether the declaration, bylaws, statute, or other governing documents gave the board the power to take the challenged action at all.

Thus, an HOA cannot necessarily defend an unauthorized rule simply by asserting that the board sincerely believed the rule would benefit the community.

Authority comes first. Business judgment generally concerns the board’s exercise of authority it actually possesses.

The Rule Does Not Necessarily Excuse a Contractual Breach

Another important limitation appears in Anderson v. Nottingham Village Homeowner’s Association, Inc., 37 A.D.3d 1195 (4th Dep’t 2007).

There, homeowners asserted a claim arising from the HOA’s alleged failure to properly repair a roof. The Fourth Department rejected the association’s reliance upon the business judgment rule as a defense to the alleged breach of contract.

The distinction is important.

A challenge to the wisdom of a discretionary board decision is different from a claim that the association failed to perform a contractual obligation it was legally required to perform.

The Business Judgment Rule in New Jersey

New Jersey also applies the business judgment rule to decisions made by condominium and homeowners’ association boards.

The New Jersey Supreme Court has expressly recognized that the rule protects residents of common-interest communities from arbitrary decision-making while also providing substantial deference to legitimate association governance.

Siller and the Fiduciary Obligations of Association Boards

An important early case is Siller v. Hartz Mountain Associates, 93 N.J. 370 (1983).

The New Jersey Supreme Court recognized that an association’s governing body has a fiduciary relationship to unit owners comparable to the obligations corporate directors owe to shareholders.

That fiduciary concept remains important in New Jersey community-association law.

Association boards possess substantial authority, but that authority is accompanied by legal obligations to the homeowners whose property interests are affected by their decisions.

Thanasoulis: Authority Comes First

Thanasoulis v. Winston Towers 200 Association, Inc., 110 N.J. 650 (1988) is another significant New Jersey Supreme Court decision.

The dispute involved a condominium association that imposed different parking charges upon resident and nonresident unit owners.

The case illustrates an essential limitation upon the business judgment rule: a board’s good-faith belief that a particular policy benefits the community does not necessarily give the board authority to adopt that policy.

The governing statute and community documents must first authorize the challenged action.

In other words:

The business judgment rule protects the exercise of legitimate discretion; it does not manufacture authority that the board does not otherwise possess.

Whittingham and New Jersey’s Two-Part Test

The Appellate Division clearly articulated New Jersey’s business judgment analysis in Owners of the Manor Homes of Whittingham v. Whittingham Homeowners Association, Inc., 367 N.J. Super. 314 (App. Div. 2004).

The court described a two-part inquiry:

  1. Was the association’s action authorized by statute or by its bylaws, master deed, or other governing documents?
  2. If authorized, was the action nevertheless fraudulent, self-dealing, or unconscionable?

If the action satisfies the business judgment standard, courts generally will not substitute their judgment for that of the association’s board.

The case itself concerned the methodology used to calculate maintenance assessments. The court concluded that the governing documents permitted an alternative method of allocating common expenses and upheld the board’s exercise of discretion.

Committee for a Better Twin Rivers

Perhaps the best-known New Jersey Supreme Court case involving a traditional homeowners’ association is *Committee for a Better Twin Rivers v. Twin Rivers Homeowners’ Association, 192 N.J. 344 (2007).

The case is principally known for addressing constitutional issues involving expressive activity within a large privately governed residential community.

For HOA law, however, the decision is also important because the New Jersey Supreme Court expressly discussed the business judgment rule.

The Court explained that the rule protects common-interest-community residents from arbitrary decision-making and reiterated the Whittingham framework: association rules may be invalidated if they lack authorization under the applicable statute or governing documents, or if the association’s conduct falls within recognized categories such as fraud, self-dealing, or unconscionability.

Twin Rivers therefore provides particularly strong authority that New Jersey’s business judgment doctrine applies to homeowners’ associations and is not confined to traditional business corporations.

Mulligan: Not Every Association Decision Is Analyzed Identically

*Mulligan v. Panther Valley Property Owners Association, 337 N.J. Super. 293 (App. Div. 2001) is another significant New Jersey common-interest-community case.

Panther Valley was a private residential development governed by a property owners’ association.

The case is particularly useful because it demonstrates that not every community-association dispute necessarily receives precisely the same analysis.

Mulligan discussed the business judgment rule but distinguished between discretionary decisions made by a board and restrictions adopted through amendments to the community’s governing documents. In the circumstances presented there, the court applied a reasonableness analysis to the challenged amendment.

The decision also discusses the fiduciary nature of association governance and the concepts of reasonableness and good faith.

Thus, before simply asking whether the “business judgment rule applies,” it may be necessary to identify exactly what type of association action is being challenged, who adopted it, and what source of authority supports it.

Micheve: An Unauthorized Action Cannot Be Saved by Business Judgment

*Micheve, L.L.C. v. Wyndham Place at Freehold Condominium Association, 381 N.J. Super. 148 (App. Div. 2005) provides a useful example of the limits of the rule.

The association imposed a capital contribution upon new purchasers.

The Appellate Division concluded that the challenged assessment was inconsistent with the Condominium Act and governing documents. Because the association lacked the necessary authority, the business judgment rule could not save the assessment.

The case reinforces the threshold question that appears repeatedly in New Jersey law:

Where did the board obtain the authority to do what it did?

Only after that question is answered does the court ordinarily reach the manner in which the board exercised its discretion.

What About Selective Enforcement in New Jersey?

Selective enforcement also presents a nuanced issue under New Jersey law.

New Jersey courts recognize that association boards owe fiduciary obligations to their members and that concepts of good faith, reasonableness, fair dealing, and protection against arbitrary decision-making are relevant to community-association governance.

At the same time, it would be too broad to state that every instance in which one homeowner is treated differently from another automatically defeats the business judgment rule.

Conversely, an association should not assume that the business judgment rule necessarily protects intentionally discriminatory, arbitrary, retaliatory, or otherwise improper enforcement simply because the underlying restriction itself is valid.

There is New Jersey case law that may provide support for different arguments depending upon the precise nature of the claimed selective enforcement, the governing documents, and the evidence.

For example, issues may arise concerning:

  • whether the allegedly comparable violations really are comparable;
  • whether the board knew of the other violations;
  • whether approval was granted in the supposedly comparable cases;
  • whether different circumstances justified different treatment;
  • whether the governing documents contain a non-waiver provision;
  • whether a history of nonenforcement may support waiver or abandonment arguments;
  • whether the board acted reasonably and in good faith;
  • whether the challenged enforcement was arbitrary;
  • whether the homeowner can demonstrate an improper motive; and
  • whether the conduct rises to the level of fraud, self-dealing, unconscionability, or another recognized basis for judicial intervention.

Accordingly, as in New York, selective enforcement should generally be analyzed on the particular facts rather than treated as an automatic defense or automatically dismissed as irrelevant.

Practical Examples of the Business Judgment Rule

Example 1: Architectural Restrictions

Assume an HOA’s governing documents authorize the board to establish architectural standards. A homeowner changes the exterior appearance of the property without obtaining required approval.

The homeowner believes the alteration improves the appearance of the property.

That ordinarily does not require a court to determine whether the homeowner or board has better aesthetic judgment.

If the restriction is authorized and the board properly exercises its authority in good faith for legitimate community purposes, the business judgment rule may provide substantial protection to the board’s decision.

New York’s Captain’s Walk case, involving the unapproved pink walkway, provides an actual example.

Example 2: “My Neighbor Did It Too”

Assume an HOA requires approval for fences. One homeowner is ordered to remove an unapproved fence but points to several other fences in the development.

That fact may be relevant, but it does not necessarily answer the legal question.

Among other things, it may be necessary to determine whether the other fences were actually subject to the same restriction, whether they received approval, whether the board knew about them, whether they predated the rule, whether the violations were materially similar, and why the association treated them differently.

There may be legal authority supporting competing arguments concerning selective enforcement depending upon the facts.

Evidence merely showing another apparent violation may present a materially different case from evidence that the board deliberately targeted a homeowner for an improper reason.

Example 3: Increasing Assessments

Suppose an HOA board determines that assessments must increase because insurance, road maintenance, landscaping, and common-area expenses have substantially increased.

A homeowner believes a smaller increase would have been sufficient.

The business judgment rule ordinarily does not invite the court to create its own HOA budget.

Instead, the questions generally concern whether the board had authority to adopt the assessment methodology and whether it exercised that authority in accordance with the applicable legal standard.

New Jersey’s Whittingham decision is a good example of judicial review of an HOA’s methodology for allocating maintenance expenses.

Example 4: An Unauthorized Fee

Suppose an association’s board decides that every new purchaser should pay a substantial capital contribution because the additional money would benefit the community.

The fact that the board believes the policy is financially beneficial does not end the analysis.

The governing documents and applicable statutes must authorize the assessment.

New Jersey’s Micheve decision demonstrates this distinction: because the challenged capital contribution lacked the necessary legal authorization, the business judgment rule could not save it.

Example 5: Choosing a Contractor

Suppose an HOA receives three proposals for replacement of a clubhouse roof and selects the middle bidder because the board believes that contractor offers better materials, warranties, experience, and references.

A homeowner believes the lowest bidder should have been selected.

Assuming the board possesses the necessary authority and acted in good faith, this is the type of discretionary management decision courts generally hesitate to second-guess.

The situation would be materially different if, for example, a board member secretly owned the selected contractor or received a financial benefit from the contract. Such circumstances could raise issues of self-dealing and breach of fiduciary duty.

Important New York Cases

Matter of Levandusky v. One Fifth Avenue Apartment Corp., 75 N.Y.2d 530 (1990)

The foundational New York Court of Appeals decision establishing the business judgment rule as the governing standard for judicial review of many residential board decisions.

40 West 67th Street v. Pullman, 100 N.Y.2d 147 (2003)

The Court of Appeals reaffirmed Levandusky and demonstrated the substantial deference afforded to a residential board acting within its authority and in good faith.

Schoninger v. Yardarm Beach Homeowners’ Association, Inc., 134 A.D.2d 1 (2d Dep’t 1987)

An important condominium decision establishing a formulation subsequently used repeatedly in HOA cases: absent fraud, self-dealing, unconscionability, or other misconduct, judicial inquiry generally focuses upon authority, good faith, and legitimate community interests.

LoRusso v. Brookside Homeowner’s Association, Inc., 17 A.D.3d 323 (2d Dep’t 2005)

A particularly useful case because the Second Department expressly applied the business judgment rule to a homeowners’ association.

Captain’s Walk Homeowners Association v. Penney, 17 A.D.3d 617 (2d Dep’t 2005)

An important HOA decision involving architectural restrictions and allegations of selective enforcement. The association prevailed where it acted within its authority and the homeowner’s selective-enforcement allegations were conclusory.

Skouras v. Victoria Hall Condominium, 73 A.D.3d 902 (2d Dep’t 2010)

Applied the business judgment rule to assessments and parking restrictions and addressed allegations of deliberate targeting and selective enforcement.

Anderson v. Nottingham Village Homeowner’s Association, Inc., 37 A.D.3d 1195 (4th Dep’t 2007)

Important for demonstrating a limitation on the doctrine: the business judgment rule did not provide a defense to the particular breach-of-contract claim concerning the HOA’s repair obligation.

Important New Jersey Cases

Papalexiou v. Tower West Condominium, 167 N.J. Super. 516 (Ch. Div. 1979)

An influential early condominium decision discussing business-judgment principles, fiduciary obligations, good faith, and judicial deference to association boards.

Siller v. Hartz Mountain Associates, 93 N.J. 370 (1983)

An important New Jersey Supreme Court decision recognizing the fiduciary relationship between a community association’s governing body and the owners.

Thanasoulis v. Winston Towers 200 Association, Inc., 110 N.J. 650 (1988)

A leading New Jersey Supreme Court decision concerning judicial review of condominium rulemaking and the limits of an association’s authority.

Mulligan v. Panther Valley Property Owners Association, 337 N.J. Super. 293 (App. Div. 2001)

An important common-interest-community case discussing the business judgment rule, fiduciary obligations, reasonableness, good faith, and the distinction between board decisions and amendments to governing restrictions.

Owners of the Manor Homes of Whittingham v. Whittingham Homeowners Association, Inc., 367 N.J. Super. 314 (App. Div. 2004)

One of the clearest statements of New Jersey’s two-part business judgment analysis: authority under statute and governing documents, followed by examination for fraud, self-dealing, or unconscionability.

Micheve, L.L.C. v. Wyndham Place at Freehold Condominium Association, 381 N.J. Super. 148 (App. Div. 2005)

An important illustration that the business judgment rule does not save an association action that lacks statutory or contractual authority.

Committee for a Better Twin Rivers v. Twin Rivers Homeowners’ Association, 192 N.J. 344 (2007)

One of New Jersey’s best-known HOA cases. The Supreme Court expressly discussed the business judgment rule in the context of a homeowners’ association and reiterated the Whittingham framework.

New York and New Jersey: Similar Principles, But Not Identical Rules

New York and New Jersey share an important underlying principle:

Courts generally do not exist to manage residential communities in place of their duly authorized governing boards.

But the rules in the two states should not be treated as identical.

In New York, Levandusky and its progeny provide substantial deference where a board acts within its authority, in good faith, and for legitimate community purposes. Courts ordinarily will not review the wisdom or soundness of the protected business decision itself.

In New Jersey, courts similarly defer to authorized association decisions. The New Jersey cases particularly emphasize the threshold question of authority under the applicable statute and governing documents and the fiduciary obligations associated with community governance. Whittingham and Twin Rivers articulate the familiar inquiry concerning authorization followed by fraud, self-dealing, or unconscionability.

Both states also demonstrate why the actual governing documents are critical. The declaration, master deed, bylaws, covenants, and rules may determine what authority the board possesses in the first place.

The Bottom Line

The business judgment rule gives homeowners’ associations substantial—but not unlimited—discretion to govern their communities.

A homeowner generally cannot overturn an HOA decision merely by showing that the homeowner disagrees with the decision, considers it unfair, or believes the board could have made a better choice.

Conversely, an HOA cannot automatically insulate every action from judicial review merely by characterizing it as an exercise of business judgment.

When evaluating an HOA dispute in New York or New Jersey, important questions may include:

  • What authority does the declaration, master deed, bylaws, applicable statute, or other governing document give the board?
  • Did the board act within that authority?
  • Was the decision made in good faith and for a legitimate community purpose?
  • Is there evidence of fraud, self-dealing, unconscionability, bad faith, discrimination, deliberate targeting, or another form of misconduct?
  • Is the challenge actually directed at the wisdom of a discretionary board decision, or does it involve an independent statutory or contractual obligation?
  • If other homeowners were allegedly treated differently, are their circumstances actually comparable?
  • What does the association’s prior enforcement history show?
  • Do the governing documents contain waiver or non-waiver provisions?
  • What evidence exists concerning the board’s reason for making the challenged decision?

The answers are highly fact-specific.

For both homeowners and associations, the business judgment rule is therefore neither an automatic defense nor an automatic obstacle to relief. Determining whether the doctrine applies requires careful examination of the governing documents, applicable statutes, board authority, enforcement history, and the circumstances surrounding the challenged decision.

Disclaimer: This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Homeowners’ association disputes are highly dependent upon the governing documents, particular facts, and applicable state law. Anyone involved in an HOA or condominium dispute should consult an attorney regarding the specific circumstances of the matter.